In this note
The JR Pass is only worth it if you take several long shinkansen rides within a few days, such as Tokyo, Kyoto, Hiroshima and back to Tokyo. Since the October 2023 price increase, individual tickets usually cost less for the classic Tokyo and Kyoto route.
We run the numbers on every Japan trip we plan, because the answer changes with the route. Here is the logic we use, without yen figures that go out of date fast.
When is the JR Pass worth it after the 2023 price increase?
In October 2023 the nationwide JR Pass went up sharply, and the math changed. A Tokyo-Kyoto round trip used to nearly cover it; now you need a lot more travel. The pass runs on consecutive days (7, 14 or 21), so it pays off when you pack several long rides into that window: for example, Tokyo, Kyoto, Hiroshima and back to Tokyo in one week, or adding Kanazawa or northern Honshu in the same period.
If your trip has only one long leg, or you fly into Tokyo and out of Osaka (or the reverse), the pass rarely adds up. In those cases we buy tickets separately, with reserved seats.
Individual tickets and regional passes: the alternatives
Individual shinkansen tickets are sold at the station or in the JR companies' apps, and on the busiest routes trains leave every few minutes. For a Tokyo, Kyoto and Osaka route they are usually the simplest and cheapest option.
Regional passes are the other alternative. JR East, JR West and other group companies sell passes that cover one area for a few days, such as Kansai with Hiroshima, the Japanese Alps up to Kanazawa, or northern Honshu. They pay off if your trip stays in that region, and we check them case by case because prices and coverage change.
| JR Pass | Individual tickets | Regional pass | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who it suits | Several long rides in a few days | Short routes or a single long leg | Trips focused on one region |
| Flexibility | Consecutive days, Nozomi only with supplement | Any train and date, Nozomi included | Only the area and days it covers |
| When it pays off | Tokyo, Kyoto, Hiroshima and back in a week | Tokyo, Kyoto and Osaka | Kansai with Hiroshima, or the Alps |
| Into Tokyo, out of Osaka | Rarely adds up | Usually the best value | Depends on the area you cover |
Nozomi or Hikari: which trains the pass covers
On the Tokaido line (Tokyo, Kyoto and Osaka) and the Sanyo line (to Hiroshima and Fukuoka), the fastest trains are the Nozomi and the Mizuho. The JR Pass does not include them: with the pass you ride the Hikari, which takes a bit longer and makes more stops, or you pay a separate supplement for the Nozomi. Between Tokyo and Kyoto the difference is about 20 to 30 minutes.
With an individual ticket you can take any train, and the Nozomi runs far more often. That is another reason individual tickets work better for us on shorter routes.

Suica, Pasmo and large suitcases on the shinkansen
Inside cities the pass is of little use: much of the Tokyo subway and Kyoto's buses are not JR. For that we use an IC card such as Suica or Pasmo, which you top up and use on subways, local trains and buses in the big cities, and also to pay at convenience stores and vending machines. On many phones you can add it to your digital wallet.
Large suitcases have their own rule. On the Tokaido, Sanyo and Kyushu shinkansen, if a bag's length, width and height add up to more than 160 cm (with a maximum of 250 cm), you need to reserve a seat with an oversized baggage area, in the last row of the car. Board without that reservation and you pay a surcharge. The option we use most is luggage forwarding: you send the suitcase from hotel to hotel, it arrives the next day, and you travel with a small bag.
How we decide on the JR Pass for each itinerary
First we map the whole route, with every train leg and its date. Then we add up the cost of individual tickets and compare it with the nationwide pass and the regional passes for that area. If the difference is small, we prefer individual tickets for the freedom to take the Nozomi and not depend on the pass's day window.
We also look at flights: flying into Tokyo and out of Osaka (or the reverse) saves a long return leg and usually tips the math against the pass. The result goes into the itinerary, with trains and times already chosen.
Frequently asked questions
Is the JR Pass worth it for Tokyo and Kyoto?
Usually not. Since the 2023 increase, individual tickets for a Tokyo-Kyoto round trip usually cost less than the 7-day pass.
Does the JR Pass include the Nozomi?
No. With the pass you ride the Hikari or Kodama, or pay a separate supplement for the Nozomi and Mizuho.
Which card is best for getting around Japanese cities?
An IC card such as Suica or Pasmo. It works on subways, local trains and buses in the big cities, and for paying at convenience stores.
Can you bring a large suitcase on the shinkansen?
Yes, but on the Tokaido, Sanyo and Kyushu lines, if its three dimensions add up to more than 160 cm, you must reserve a seat with an oversized baggage area. Without it you pay a surcharge.
Are there regional rail passes in Japan?
Yes. Several JR companies sell passes for one area and a few days, such as Kansai with Hiroshima or the Japanese Alps. They pay off if your trip stays in that region.
Destinations in this note

Franco & Vicky
We're Argentinian, we live in Sydney and we've traveled to more than 40 countries. Every note comes from what we lived ourselves, not from a brochure.
Get to know us @dos.inquietos


